IEEE7000-ConceptExploration-Context-OperationalEnvironment | IEEE 7000 Clause 5.1 - Concept Exploration + Context + Operational Environment + Use Cases + System Definition | 0 |
IEEE7000-EthicalRequirements-ValueBased-Traceability-DesignIntegration | IEEE 7000 Clauses 7 + 7.1 - Ethical Requirements Definition + Value-Based Requirements + Traceability + System Engineering Design Integration + AI Validation | 0 |
IEEE7000-EthicalRisk-Identification-Analysis-Treatment-ValidationOutcomes | IEEE 7000 Clauses 8 + 8.1 + 8.2 - Ethical Risk Identification + Analysis + Treatment + Validation of Ethical Outcomes + AI Safety + Robustness + Adversarial Protection | 67 |
IEEE7000-Governance-Culture-Integration-Measurement-Accountability-Roles | IEEE 7000 - Governance + Culture + Roles + Training + Integration with System Engineering + Measurement + Improvement + Accountability Framework for AI | 0 |
IEEE7000-Operations-Lifecycle-OngoingMonitoring-Incident-Decommissioning | IEEE 7000 - Operations + Lifecycle + Ongoing AI Risk Monitoring + Data Provenance + Retention + Privacy + Safe Deployment + Decommissioning + Disposal | 33 |
IEEE7000-Scope-VBE-EAD-IEEE7000Family-EUAIAct-NIST-ISO42001-Coord | IEEE 7000-2021 - Scope + Value-Based Engineering (VBE) + Ethically Aligned Design + IEEE 7000 Family + Coordination EU AI Act + NIST AI RMF + ISO/IEC 42001 | 19 |
IEEE7000-Stakeholders-DirectIndirectMarginalised-Engagement-CoDesign | IEEE 7000 Clauses 5.2 + 5.3 - Stakeholder Identification + Engagement + Direct + Indirect + Marginalised + Co-Design + Human Oversight | 0 |
IEEE7000-Transparency-Communication-Documentation-ExternalReview-Audit | IEEE 7000 Clause 9 - Transparency + Communication + Process Documentation + External Review + Third-Party Audit + AI Documentation + Algorithmic Transparency + User Notification | 2 |
IEEE7000-Values-Elicitation-Prioritisation-IEEE7000Family-Bias-Privacy-Transparency | IEEE 7000 Clauses 6 + 6.1 - Ethical Values Elicitation + Prioritisation + IEEE 7000 Family Integration (Bias + Privacy + Transparency + Wellbeing) | 66 |
1-3 | Overview, normative references and definitions | 0 |
10 | Ethical Risk-Based Design Process | 0 |
10.2 | Ethical Risk-Based Design outcomes | 0 |
10.3(a) | Prepare for and produce an ethically aligned design | 0 |
10.3(b) | Identify design feasibility risks with stakeholders | 0 |
10.3(c) | Analyse and specify technical and organizational control over the system | 0 |
10.3(d) | Select pragmatic treatment options for the design work products | 0 |
10.3(e) | Verify and validate the ethically aligned design and keep it under review | 0 |
11 | Transparency Management Process | 0 |
11.2 | Transparency Management outcomes | 0 |
11.3(a) | Prepare to manage transparency: organizational rules and their enforcement | 0 |
11.3(b) | Share information about the ethical content of the system | 0 |
11.3(c) | Share information about the availability of the collected information through the Case for Ethics | 0 |
5 | Key concepts and application | 0 |
6 | Key roles in Ethical Value Engineering project teams | 0 |
6.2 | Role descriptions: the eight roles and their responsibilities | 0 |
6.3 | Team competency | 0 |
7 | Concept of Operations (ConOps) and Context Exploration Process | 0 |
7.2 | ConOps and Context Exploration outcomes | 0 |
7.3(a) | Develop an understanding of the system's intended contexts of use | 0 |
7.3(b) | Identify stakeholders who may be interested in or affected by the system | 0 |
7.3(c) | Describe and analyse technical and organizational control over the envisaged system | 0 |
7.3(d) | Obtain access to the enabling systems or services to be used | 0 |
7.3(e) | Gather social, legal and environmental information on feasibility | 0 |
7.3(f) | Identify and represent one or more system concepts of operations | 0 |
7.3(g) | Resolve gaps between the value-based ConOps and alternative ConOps descriptions | 0 |
7.3(h) | Complete the concept and context analyses and decide on further ethical treatment | 0 |
8 | Ethical Values Elicitation and Prioritization Process | 0 |
8.2 | Ethical Values Elicitation and Prioritization outcomes | 0 |
8.3(a) | Choose the stakeholders whose values are to be elicited | 0 |
8.3(b) | Elicit and record stakeholder values relevant to the ConOps | 0 |
8.3(c) | Analyse and organize the elicited values into value clusters | 0 |
8.3(d) | Prioritise the core values | 0 |
8.3(e) | Identify and record risks and opportunities affecting the values | 0 |
8.3(f) | Perform a conceptual value analysis and refine the prioritised value clusters | 0 |
8.3(g) | Obtain approval for the prioritised values | 0 |
9 | Ethical Requirements Definition Process | 0 |
9.2 | Ethical Requirements Definition outcomes | 0 |
9.3(a) | Formulate and record ethical value requirements | 0 |
9.3(b) | Validate the ethical value requirements with stakeholders | 0 |
9.3(c) | Formulate and record the value-based system requirements arising from each EVR | 0 |
9.3(d) | Evaluate and adjust the ethical and value-based requirements | 0 |
9.3(e) | Analyse, trace and record the further handling of value-based requirements | 0 |
ANNEXES | Annexes A to J (informative) | 0 |