3.1(a) | 3.1(a) Specified, legitimate purposes and data that are adequate, relevant and not excessive | 1 |
3.1(b) | 3.1(b) Proportionality and subsidiarity, whatever the legal ground, tested before monitoring starts | 1 |
3.1(c) | 3.1(c) Let workers exercise access, rectification, erasure and blocking | 1 |
3.1(d) | 3.1(d) Accurate data kept no longer than needed, with a set retention period | 1 |
3.1(e) | 3.1(e) Security of monitoring data and staff awareness of data protection duties | 1 |
3.1.1(a) | 3.1.1(a) Consent is not the legal ground for most processing at work; default settings are not consent | 1 |
3.1.1(b) | 3.1.1(b) Contract and legal obligation as grounds, with workers fully informed of legally required processing | 1 |
3.1.1(c) | 3.1.1(c) Legitimate interest: a legitimate purpose, a necessary and least intrusive method, a demonstrated balance | 1 |
3.1.1(d) | 3.1.1(d) Limits on monitoring: places, data and time | 1 |
3.1.2 | 3.1.2 Tell workers that monitoring exists, why, and what else fairness requires | 1 |
3.1.3 | 3.1.3 No decision based solely on automated evaluation of work performance without a permitted ground | 1 |
3.2.1 | 3.2.1 Data protection by design and default in monitoring devices and tools | 1 |
3.2.2 | 3.2.2 Data protection impact assessment for high-risk monitoring and prior consultation if residual risk stays high | 1 |
4 | 4 No incompatible further use of monitoring data | 1 |
5.1(a) | 5.1(a) Recruitment: social media and public data only with a legal ground, when relevant to the job, and with prior notice | 1 |
5.1(b) | 5.1(b) Recruitment data deleted once no offer is made or it is declined | 1 |
5.2(a) | 5.2(a) No generalised screening of employees' social media during employment | 1 |
5.2(b) | 5.2(b) No demand for access to what employees or applicants share on social networks | 1 |
5.2(c) | 5.2(c) Employees keep a private profile; no compulsory employer-provided profile | 1 |
5.3(a) | 5.3(a) Network and TLS inspection tuned to prevent permanent logging of employee activity | 1 |
5.3(b) | 5.3(b) Exclude sensitive traffic from inspection and tell employees what is monitored | 1 |
5.3(c) | 5.3(c) Policy on who may access suspicious log data and when, reviewed at least annually | 1 |
5.3(d) | 5.3(d) Acceptable use and privacy policies implemented and communicated before monitoring | 1 |
5.3(e) | 5.3(e) Involve a representative sample of employees, and the works council where the law requires it | 1 |
5.3(f) | 5.3(f) Data loss prevention: transparent rules and a warning before an email is blocked | 1 |
5.3(g) | 5.3(g) Private spaces in employer-provided online applications | 1 |
5.3(h) | 5.3(h) Prefer prevention to detection: block rather than monitor | 1 |
5.4.1 | 5.4.1 Home and remote working: no keystroke, mouse, screen or webcam capture | 1 |
5.4.2(a) | 5.4.2(a) Bring your own device: separate private from business use and keep out of private areas | 1 |
5.4.2(b) | 5.4.2(b) Bring your own device: secure the employer's data, weigh monitoring during personal use, or bar private use | 1 |
5.4.3 | 5.4.3 Mobile device management: DPIA first, a specified purpose, tracking held back until a device is lost | 1 |
5.4.4 | 5.4.4 Wearables: health and activity data stay with the employee | 1 |
5.5 | 5.5 Time and attendance and access control: informed, necessary, and not reused for performance evaluation | 1 |
5.6 | 5.6 Video monitoring: no video analytics of expressions or movements, no facial recognition | 1 |
5.7(a) | 5.7(a) Vehicle tracking: necessary, proportionate, with a private-use opt-out and no evaluation of drivers | 1 |
5.7(b) | 5.7(b) Tell drivers a tracker is fitted and that movements, and possibly driving behaviour, are recorded; notice in the vehicle | 1 |
5.7(c) | 5.7(c) No location monitoring outside agreed working hours, save a proportionate theft safeguard | 1 |
5.7.1 | 5.7.1 Event data recorders and in-cab cameras: only where necessary and proportionate; no continuous recording of drivers | 1 |
5.8 | 5.8 Disclosure of employee data to customers only where proportionate | 1 |
5.9 | 5.9 International transfers of HR and monitoring data: adequacy preferred, minimum data, limited group access | 1 |
6.1 | 6.1 Owning the equipment does not remove employees' secrecy of communications; location tracking only where strictly necessary | 1 |
CONTEXT | Sections 2 to 4: why the Opinion was needed, the legal framework and the risks | 0 |
OPINION | Opinion 2/2017 (WP249): what it is and its status | 0 |